The Reference Test: Would Your Former Manager Hire You Again?
The Reference Test: Would Your Former Manager Hire You Again?
By John Crager, CMRP, SHRM-SCP | Next Shift Blog at WorkReady.works Published October 2026 | ~1,500 words | 6 min read
Part 5 of a 10-part series.
Near the end of most reference calls, after the dates and the duties and the polite warm-up, comes one last question.
"Would you hire her again?"
Then there's a gap before the answer. Sometimes it's no gap at all: "In a heartbeat." Sometimes it's a full second, followed by, "Well, in the right role, sure."
Both people said yes. Only one of them helped.
Hiring managers listen for that pause the way a mechanic listens to an engine. The words that follow barely matter. A fast, unqualified yes tells them what a resume and three interviews can't. A slow one tells them something as well.
So here's a question worth asking before you start your next search, while you still have time to do something about the answer. If somebody called your last three managers tomorrow and asked whether they'd hire you again, what would each one say? And how quickly?
What a Reference Really Is
We tend to treat references as paperwork. Three names, three phone numbers, a box on a form.
A reference is something else: an independent account of what it was like to work with you. Not what you did. Your resume covers that. What you were like while doing it.
Were you dependable when it was inconvenient? Constructive when the pressure was on, or did you get sharp with people? Could you be trusted with sensitive information? Did you keep others informed, or did they have to chase you? And did the work get delivered?
Notice that only the last item is about results. The rest is about the experience of having you on the team. Which is exactly what a new employer can't see for themselves and badly wants to know.
Run the Test Yourself
Take a sheet of paper and list every person who has supervised you over the past ten years. Next to each name, write your honest guess at how they'd answer the rehire question. Four categories cover it:
- Enthusiastic yes. They'd say so without being asked twice, and they'd have a story ready.
- Qualified yes. Positive, with a "but" or an "in the right role" attached.
- Don't know. You parted on neutral terms, or it's been long enough that you can't predict it.
- Probably not. Something went wrong, and you both know it.
Be accurate, not generous. Nobody sees this page except you.
Most people find the exercise uncomfortable for about ten minutes and useful for years. And let me be clear about its purpose. This isn't an invitation to beat yourself up over a job that ended badly in 2017. It's a reputation check, the same way you'd check your credit before applying for a mortgage. You're finding out what's on the record so nothing surprises you later.
Widen the Circle
Managers aren't the only people who saw you work, and they aren't always the best witnesses. A supervisor who met with you once a week knows less about your daily habits than the colleague two desks over.
So extend the list. Who else can speak credibly about your work?
Peers, first. They know whether you carried your share and whether you were decent to deal with on a bad day. Customers and clients saw how you behaved when something went wrong on their account. Partners, vendors, and contractors can tell an employer how you treat people you have leverage over, which says a great deal. And if you've managed others, the people who reported to you hold the most revealing view of all.
Run the same four-category sort on each. You'll probably find a pattern. Maybe managers rate you highly and peers would hesitate, or the reverse. Whatever shows up, that pattern is the most valuable thing the test produces, because it points at a habit and not a single incident.
Turning "Don't Know" Into an Answer
The don't-knows are the easiest to fix. You ask.
Not "Will you be a reference?" That question gets a reflexive yes from nearly everybody, including people who'll then give a lukewarm account. Ask something that's harder to answer on autopilot:
"I'm starting to look at operations director roles. If somebody called you, would you feel comfortable speaking to the work we did on the warehouse consolidation? If you'd rather not, or you don't feel you saw enough of it, I completely understand."
That last sentence is doing real work. It hands the person a graceful way out, and you want them to take it if they need it. A reference who hesitates when you ask will hesitate more when a stranger calls. Better to find out now, from them, than later from a rejection you can't explain.
When they say yes, and most will, listen to how. Warmth and specifics mean you've got an enthusiastic one. A flat "sure, happy to" means you've got a name on a list.
The Hard Category
Then there are the probably-nots. Nearly everyone with a long career has one. A manager you clashed with, a role that was a poor fit, a departure that got messy.
You have four moves, and you can use more than one.
Leave them off. You choose your references, and nobody expects a list of every boss you've ever had. Offset them with somebody else from the same employer, a peer or a senior leader in another department, so that chapter of your career still has a credible voice. Prepare your own short account of what happened, because a thorough employer may make calls beyond your list. Two or three calm sentences: what the situation was, what you'd do differently, what you took from it. No blame. And where you owe somebody an acknowledgment, consider making it.
That fourth one is optional and it isn't a tactic. But a short, sincere note years later ("I've thought about how I handled that handoff, and I'd do it differently now") sometimes changes how a person remembers you. Sometimes it doesn't. Send it only if you mean it.
What you shouldn't do is pretend the chapter never happened or trash the other party in an interview. Hiring managers have all had a difficult boss. They're watching how you talk about yours.
Keep Your Yeses Warm
Your enthusiastic references are an asset, and assets need maintenance.
Contact them before you list them, every time, even if they've done it before. Tell them what you're pursuing and why. Remind them of the two or three projects they saw up close, since they've managed plenty of people after you and details fade. Send your current resume, and when a specific role is in play, send the job description too so they can speak to the fit. I've written before on this blog about how to pick and aim references, and all of it still applies.
The bigger point is what happens between searches. Stay in touch when you need nothing. Tell them how things turned out. Congratulate them when they move up. Professional goodwill takes years to build, and it's built in exactly those small, unrequested contacts.
Your Move This Week
Four steps, about an hour.
Write the list: every manager from the last ten years, plus five peers, clients, or partners who saw your work closely. Sort all of them into the four categories. Pick two don't-knows and ask them the comfortable-speaking question. Then draft your short, blame-free account of the one chapter you'd rather not discuss, and say it out loud until it sounds calm.
The Bottom Line
Every job leaves behind a group of people with an opinion about what you were like to work with. You don't get to write that opinion. You do get to know what it is, and you get a say in what the next group thinks.
Run the test before somebody else runs it for you. Find out who would say yes without a pause. Fix what can be fixed, plan around what can't, and look after the people who'd vouch for you.
Would they hire you again? Better to know than to guess.
John Crager, CMRP, SHRM-SCP, is a heavy industry operations and planning professional with decades of experience in refinery and petrochemical environments. He is the author of Blue Collar Resume Mastery and Beyond Thank You for Your Service, available on Amazon, and writes about career navigation, credentials, and the future of the industrial workforce.
Follow the data. Trust the signal. Skip the noise.
→ Next in this series: Your First 90 Days Are Not an Audition. They Are the Start of Your Reputation.
← Previously: Networking Is Not Asking for a Job. It Is Staying Useful and Visible.